I was watching Okto channel the other day, where they featured a group of workers extracting sulfur near a volcano in indonesia.
Sulfur extraction.
And there were sulfuric fumes in the area too.
All the workers had for protection was a piece of cloth to cover their mouth and nose, a pair of rubber boats for the walk up and down the area, where they carried the sulfur rocks in two baskets connected by a pole, on their shoulders.
Talk about health risk. Their shoulder is slightly sunken in, some even exposing slight flesh, as the pole was rubbing against their shoulder as they carried the rocks, and those rocks are heavy. One of them even showed off his ghastly teeth, suspecting the deformation caused by the excessive sulfur fumes.
It was a relatively high paying job. They earn around $10~20 per day, I think. Or was it $1~2. I could not recall. But they earn more than farmers I believe. But they could not hope to earn it for too long. This is, after all, a job with health hazard. One day they might just collapse during work, dead from all the fumes.
Then the scene cut to a professor in US, who said something along this line,"They chose short term economic gain over long term health".
The professor might not have meant it as a critisim, but I felt offended by that statement. This is clearly a statement from someone who had never been poor.
If anyone had a choice, would they do such a work that is so health-hazardous? He had a family to feed. A wife and two children. They had no other skills. Not many people had the luxury to be educated. They might not even know their letters (alphabates).
One might said that farming is a safer choice. But farming has its risk too. Natural disasters, climate changes. Fire. Anything could wipe out a harvest. And who could he rely on to feed his family?
The same could be said of many other cases. We looked at someone and wondered how they could work under such conditions. It could be one where the person had to endure embrassment, lack of pride and dignity, health risk, mental stress, etc. It could be where the person was living in an inhumane environment or working in one. And we called them names, urging them to live more like a human, and leave the place.
We were never in their shoes. They could have no choice. We had never been poor where we were unable to find our next meal. We had never been in a situation to dig for food from a rubbish dump. We had never been poor enough to sleep in a cockroach infested place. They found a way out of that, and despite it being inhumane, they had meals, and a place to stay.
Rather than critise them about being 'stupid' and 'short-sighted', a more responsible action should be to help them. I have no right to critise them, but neither do I have any idea on how to help them.
I respect the indonesia workers. In fact, one of the person was trying to work very hard to save enough for his children's education. Surely so that his children need not live the same life as him. He is a great father, risking his life so that his family could live. Truely a man.