I was chatting with my collegues, and something blurted out before I could think through properly (I should learn to control my tongue). Not that it is anything offending to them, but I am definitely making a sterotype here, which is bad.
We were talking about doctors being highly paid professional. And I commented that surgeons need to be able to not commit too much emotion into every operations.
First off, I apologize for the sterotype. They should be emotionally attached to their patients, and view all of them as precious life to be saved. What I said was rather unthoughtful.
The reason I made such a statement was probably the result of various movies and drama. Usually the kind who cared most are the ones who are deeply affected when their patients die. And watching them suffered made me ponder if it would be better if they did not invest such emotions in the patients.
And of course, in movies, the other extreme of the sterotypes appear too. There will be those who treat it as a job.
'Professionals', as some would call themselves as. Patients are but items to them. A trophy to their 'resume' if successful. Forgotten quickly if failed. In fact they would target those operations or patients which would make themselves famous. Perhaps a famous politician, or a rare disease to operate on. And if the success rate is too low they would avoid the operation. All the media publicity, and none of the 'work ethnics' as some might ask of surgeons and doctors.
And following up that was a joke made by my collegue. That we as solution/software provider should probably employ the same 'attitude'. To not be personally and emotionally invested in our work. Defects will always exist. There will always be requests and additional requirement changes.But solution/software development is not the focus of this blog.
I take pride in my work. I try to make it as defect free as I can, within limits. Workarounds and compromises can be provided if a defect cannot be solved, and changing requirements, if reasonable and easy to do, could be implemented.
But if you applied that in the context of the doctor, that would be akin like a doctor telling a patient to avoid walking because there is no way to properly heal his legs (a workaround to a defect), or telling a patient that he has no cure and he has to live with it (an irritating but non-fatal cancer), or even to just take a nap when he could not bear the pain in his head (rebooting the machine when the software crashes).
What am I driving at? Honestly, I am not sure. I'm just slightly confused here.
If I, in my work as a software developer, employs such an attitude and 'professionalism' to my projects, should I be upset at how doctors and surgeons are when they treat life lightly?
Of course, the main difference is that one of them deals with life & death, and the other, while.. not that critical most of the times (though if we talk about software for the space shuttle, airplane, etc those are as critical, and bank software might indirectly be life threatening too).
Guess before I criticize the work ethnics of others I should look at my own work ethnics. No, make that a general statement for criticism.